inquiring minds want to know.

Melissa seems to me more cohesive, slightly stronger material.

oath. OATH.

fuck you, I am the pessimist and I have to say oath blows melissa away, though I like both. Maybe its because I am the Pessimist but I like Oath better. Its sad when everyone is like, yeah man death rules, yeah man metallica rules, yeah man iron maiden, yeah man slayer, yeah man everyother trendy filth bad band that has come out, when truth is we all need to hail the one and only king, because he brought us the true wicked music, not metal, but music. Metal seems to be such a degrading term, though I love most bands that are called "Metal". Fuck ozzy and all other rip offs, there was so much satanism in the 60s and 70's that predates all that modern bullshit. Black Mass Lucifer is all I have to say and that was way before fag bags black sabath. By the way I only see the NOSE, I am the Pessimist

and by the way I do like death, metallica, and iron maiden, I am just saying they are not the original kings, though I am the Pessimist and I only see the NOSE...

i love oath, but nothing beats melissa, in my opinion. i love that record more than almost anything.

I'm going to go with Melissa.

lol......wut?

melissa all the way

oath has a really weak guitar sound and a slight bit of filler...far from the perfect album it's made out to be.